Navigating Inflation: Why Insuring to Value Matters for Homeowners in CT

April 30, 2024

Adequate homeowners insurance in Connecticut is increasingly critical in the face of economic unpredictability and rising inflation. Homeowners confront significant challenges in protecting their most valuable financial asset, which also holds immense emotional value. They must deal with the reality that they, and their insurance companies, are battling the increasing costs of materials, labor, and other expenses, compounded by both an unpredictable economy and weather conditions. 

Finding affordable and appropriate home insurance options can be challenging. Some industry leaders estimate a 9% increase in Connecticut’s rates in 2024, ranking it one of the highest in the nation. This is in part due to growing claims. According to a CT Insider report, in 2022, Connecticut property and casualty insurance claims totaled close to $6.4 billion, up for a fourth consecutive year from $5.9 billion in 2021 — a rising trend for over a decade.

Insuring to Replacement Cost Value: The Key to Sufficient Coverage

In this environment, the temptation to underinsure to save money on homeowners insurance can be strong. However, ensuring adequate coverage is crucial for protecting your Connecticut home for several reasons. 

By insuring to replacement cost value, you ensure your homeowners insurance policy provides enough coverage to rebuild your entire home in the event of severe damage or a total loss. The ascending policy limits must account for the escalating costs of materials, labor, and other expenses. 

This part of coverage is vital because the rebuilding cost can far exceed your home’s purchase price or market value, especially during periods of high inflation. Where you would probably not sell your home for its assessed value, the insurance company can most likely not rebuild it for the market value. Therefore, if your homeowners insurance replacement costs fall short, you’ll be responsible for covering the remaining costs out of your own pocket. Carrying such a financial burden can be disastrous and sometimes impossible without adequate protection, particularly in cases of total loss that require rebuilding from the ground up.

Obtaining an accurate and detailed inspection of your home before purchasing it is critical for risk reduction and identifying the most likely threats to your property. It’s prudent and wise to order a professional home inspection to protect your investment and ensure you continue to have adequate homeowners insurance values. Working with insurance professionals, such as the experienced and dedicated team at Brooks, Todd & McNeil, can help you maintain the integrity and safety of your property.

The Impact of Inflation on Rebuilding Costs

The overall cost of construction increases proportionally with the escalating prices of materials such as lumber, drywall, and roofing. The consequences of inflation may have rendered your home’s coverage inadequate, even if it was sufficiently insured a few years ago.

As an illustration, the National Association of Home Builders’ most recent Building Cost Index indicates that the price of constructing a new home in the United States rose by more than 35% between 2020 and 2022. This significant surge underscores the necessity of routinely evaluating and modifying one’s homeowners insurance coverage to align with the escalating expenses.

Additional Living Expenses Coverage: A Lifeline During Rebuilding

It is equally important to review additional living expenses (ALE) coverage to verify that one’s dwelling coverage is adequate for a residence’s reconstruction. While your home is being repaired or rebuilt, this coverage assists with food, temporary housing, and other essential living expenses.

Because of labor shortages, supply chain complications, and additional variables, the duration of repairs or reconstruction has become prolonged and is now about twice the former normal amount of time. Due to the possibility of a protracted temporary living situation, it may be necessary to increase your ALE coverage.

Avoiding Coinsurance Penalties

Under most homeowner’s insurance policies, one must maintain a certain percentage of coverage relative to the replacement cost value to avoid penalties. Should you fall short, you may be subject to a coinsurance penalty, which can substantially reduce the amount you receive in the event of a claim if you fail to comply with this requirement, and therefore, substantially increase your out-of-pocket expenses to rebuild.

It is critical to collaborate closely with your insurance agent to ensure your coverage accurately reflects your home’s current value and potential rebuilding cost to avoid coinsurance penalties. By maintaining open communication with your agent and conducting routine home appraisals, you can stay ahead of inflation and avoid costly penalties.

Tips for Homeowners in CT

As a Connecticut homeowner, it is incumbent on you to be proactive and take appropriate steps to protect your family’s haven and most valuable asset. Here are some tips to help guide you through the maze of insuring your home to its replacement value during inflationary times:

  • Evaluate your homeowners insurance policy regularly, either annually or whenever significant life events take place, such as home remodeling or additions.
  • Use online calculators or consult a professional appraiser to estimate your home’s current rebuilding cost, considering local construction costs and inflation rates.
  • Discuss your coverage requirements with an experienced insurance agent who can assist you in adjusting your policy limits and providing adequate protection.
  • Consider asking for an inflation guard endorsement in your policy. This endorsement automatically increases your coverage limits yearly to keep up with rising costs. 
  • Stay current on changes in the housing market, construction costs, and economic conditions that may affect the value of your home and the cost of rebuilding.

At Brooks, Todd & McNeil, we understand homeowners’ challenges in navigating inflation and ensuring adequate coverage. Our team of experienced agents is dedicated to providing personalized guidance and tailored solutions to protect your home and your financial well-being. 

Contact us today at (800) 448-4567 to review your homeowners insurance policy and be confident you are insured to replacement cost value.

About Brooks, Todd & McNeil

Since 1839, the independent agents at Brooks, Todd & McNeil have been pleased to offer our community the best and most affordable policies from a variety of providers. Our dedicated facilitators are ready to put their 75 years of combined experience to work on your claims. To learn more about our products and services, contact us today at (800) 448-4567.